This is fantastic, I'm purchasing this color for the fourth time.

The lip liner's color isn't very intense. It looks like a medium dark grey, not black. The velvet liquid lipstick is a good black color. It dries completely matte and doesn't have any weird smell. It's great. The lip gloss is very opaque and a nice, dark black. However, IT SMELLS TERRIBLE, like cat urine. I'm not sure if I can wear it on my lips because the smell lingers even after an hour on my hand. So, that's a disappointment for me. Also, the lip liner and lip gloss came off easily with a light wipe from a paper towel, while the velvet liquid lipstick is a bit more long-lasting, which is good.

The lip liner in this set is a solid, medium dusty rose, not a light pink, but I still really like the color. The velvet liquid lipstick is also dusty rose, dries completely matte, and has a subtle vanilla scent, which is great. However, the lip gloss is opaque and has a terrible, cat pee-like smell. The smell lingers even after an hour. This is a disappointment. The lip liner and lip gloss easily come off after a light wipe with a paper towel, while the velvet liquid lipstick is more long-lasting, which is a positive.

Same as the image.